Wisdom about the Crowd: Assuring Geospatial Data Quality Collected in Location-Based Games
نویسندگان
چکیده
The idea of outsourcing geospatial data creation tasks to the crowd (volunteered geographic information, VGI) has become quite popular in the field of geographic information science (GIScience). As one approach to VGI, location-based games (LBGs) have been shown to be successful in motivating non-expert users to collect and tag geospatial data. However, the central VGI problem of data quality has so far not been solved satisfyingly. Previous studies show that games that reward their players for inor post-game data reviewing can assure only a validation rate of about 40% of the data. We address this problem with a new LBG design pattern, based on game rules that encourage players to take the decisions of others into account while making their data collecting decisions. We empirically evaluate the new pattern by comparing the positional accuracy of data collected with two different rule sets for the LBG GeoSnake. Our pattern is shown to result in a significant accuracy improvement.
منابع مشابه
Assuring the Quality of Volunteered Geographic Information
Volunteered geographic information (VGI) is a phenomenon of recent years, offering an alternative mechanism for the acquisition and compilation of geographic information. As such it offers substantial advantages, but suffers from a general lack of quality assurance. We discuss the issues involved in the determination of quality for geospatial data, and trace the history of research on VGI quali...
متن کاملPair Me Up: A Web Framework for Crowd-Sourced Spoken Dialogue Collection
We describe and analyze a new web-based spoken dialogue data collection framework. The framework enables the capture of conversational speech from two remote users who converse with each other and play a dialogue game entirely through their web browsers. We report on the substantial improvements in the speed and cost of data capture we have observed with this crowd-sourced paradigm. We also ana...
متن کاملUsing Qualitative Spatial Logic for Validating Crowd-Sourced Geospatial Data
We describe a tool, MatchMaps, that generates sameAs and partOf matches between spatial objects (such as shops, shopping centres, etc.) in crowd-sourced and authoritative geospatial datasets. MatchMaps uses reasoning in qualitative spatial logic, description logic and truth maintenance techniques, to produce a consistent set of matches. We report the results of an initial evaluation of MatchMap...
متن کاملLocation Estimation Using Crowdsourced Geospatial Narratives
The “crowd” has become a very important geospatial data provider. Subsumed under the term Volunteered Geographic Information (VGI), non-expert users have been providing a wealth of quantitative geospatial data online. With spatial reasoning being a basic form of human cognition, narratives expressing geospatial experiences, e.g., travel blogs, would provide an even bigger source of geospatial d...
متن کاملMobile Crowd Sensing
People-centric sensing with smart phones can be used for large scale sensing of the physical world at low cost by leveraging the available sensors on the phones. Despite its benefits, mobile people-centric sensing has two main issues: (i) incentivizing the participants, and (ii) reliability of the sensed data. Unfortunately, the existing solutions to solve these issue either requires infrastruc...
متن کامل